How Often Do Favourites Win in Football? We Checked 6,331 Matches Against Club Elo

We checked every match of Europe's five big leagues since August 2023, and 575 Champions League matches, against Club Elo ratings. The favourite wins about half the time, an away favourite less often, and the day-one No. 1 took 10 of 15 league titles.

··Melbo Editorial·14 min
How Often Do Favourites Win in Football? We Checked 6,331 Matches Against Club Elo

The favourite wins about half the time. In the 5,756 matches played in Europe's five biggest leagues since August 2023, the club with the higher Club Elo rating before kick-off won 51.3%, drew 25.4% and lost 23.3%. In the Champions League the favourite won 59.8% of 575 matches. The rating gap and the venue change the picture: a slight favourite playing away won 26% of the time, a heavy favourite at home 87%.

The next test is Champions League matchday 5 on 24 and 25 November 2026, with Arsenal v Borussia Dortmund, Manchester City v Napoli, Paris Saint-Germain v Roma and Lille v Bayern Munich among its 18 matches.

How often does the favourite win a football match?

About one match in two. Across the Premier League, La Liga, the Bundesliga, Serie A and Ligue 1 from August 2023 to 8 November 2026, the higher-rated club won 2,953 of 5,756 matches. It avoided defeat in 76.7% of them, because a quarter of all matches ended level.

"Favourite" here means one thing only: the club with more Club Elo points before the match. Club Elo rates every club from its results, adding points for a win and removing them for a defeat, more so when the result was unexpected. In November 2026 the top of its table is Bayern Munich and Arsenal on 2,047 points, Barcelona on 2,033 and Manchester City on 2,003.

The share is steady from season to season: 51.8% in 2023/24, 52.5% in 2024/25, 49.5% in 2025/26 and 51.6% so far in 2026/27. One reason it stays near a half is that most league matches are close contests. In 53.5% of them the two clubs were fewer than 100 Elo points apart.

How big does the rating gap have to be?

The favourite starts to win more than half of its matches at about 100 Elo points. Below 25 points the "favourite" won less often than the underdog.

Top-league results by Club Elo gap: the favourite won 34% at 0–24 points, 45% at 50–99, 56% at 100–149, 69% at 200–299 and 82% at 300 or more
Top-league results by Club Elo gap: the favourite won 34% at 0–24 points, 45% at 50–99, 56% at 100–149, 69% at 200–299 and 82% at 300 or more
  • Under 50 points the rating tells you little. At 0–24 points the favourite won 34.4% and the underdog 36.5%. At 25–49 points it was 38.9% against 30.7%.
  • At 100–149 points the favourite won 55.5%. Arsenal and Liverpool are 110 points apart in November 2026.
  • At 300 points or more it won 82.1% of 195 matches and lost 5.6%. A gap that size is Arsenal against Sunderland: 2,047 points against 1,727.
  • Draws shrink as the gap grows, from 29–30% between equals to 12% at 300 points or more.

Does home advantage matter more than the rating?

In a close match, yes. When the two clubs were fewer than 50 points apart and the higher-rated one played away, the home side won 39.8%, 30.9% were drawn and the favourite won 29.3%.

Matches won by the higher-rated club at home and away: 43% and 26% at 0–24 points, 51% and 40% at 50–99, 72% and 58% at 150–199, 87% and 77% at 300 or more
Matches won by the higher-rated club at home and away: 43% and 26% at 0–24 points, 51% and 40% at 50–99, 72% and 58% at 150–199, 87% and 77% at 300 or more
  • A favourite at home won 58.2% of its matches, a favourite away 44.5%.
  • An away favourite needs about 150 points to win more often than not. At 100–149 points it won 48.3%; at 150–199 points 57.5%.
  • The home side won 43.3% of all league matches, 25.4% were drawn and the visitors won 31.4%. La Liga had the most home wins (45.6%), Serie A the fewest (40.7%).

Club Elo builds this into its own forecasts as a bonus for the home side. On 8 November 2026 the bonus was 39 points in Ligue 1, 45 in Serie A, 49 in the Premier League, 51 in the Bundesliga and 66 in La Liga. That matches what the results show: under about 50 points, playing at home is worth more than the rating gap.

Which league is the hardest to call?

None stands out. The favourite's share in the five leagues runs from 50.2% to 52.1%.

Favourite won, draw, underdog won: Champions League 60%, 16%, 24%; Serie A 52%, 27%, 21%; Premier League 51%, 25%, 24%; Ligue 1 50%, 24%, 26%
Favourite won, draw, underdog won: Champions League 60%, 16%, 24%; Serie A 52%, 27%, 21%; Premier League 51%, 25%, 24%; Ligue 1 50%, 24%, 26%
  • Ligue 1 had the most underdog wins: 26.2% of 1,008 matches.
  • Serie A had the most draws (27.0%) and the fewest underdog wins (20.9%).
  • The Premier League sits in the middle: 51.0% favourite, 24.7% draw, 24.4% underdog.

Is the Champions League easier to call than the leagues?

Before the knockouts, yes. In the 2023/24 group stage and the league phases played since, the favourite won 61.8% of 456 matches. The field is less even than a domestic league: counting all rounds, a club rated 200 points or more above its opponent won 81% of 110 matches. Home advantage is also larger. Club Elo's home bonus for Champions League matches is about 75 points, and across all rounds a favourite at home won 69.4% of the time against 50.7% away.

The knockout rounds are different. Over 119 knockout matches from 2023/24 to 2025/26 the favourite won 52.1% in 90 minutes, 20.2% were level and the underdog won 27.7%. In the 12 semi-final legs of those three seasons the higher-rated club won twice.

The league phase introduced in 2024 has produced more underdog wins than the old groups: 24.7% of 360 matches against 15.6% of 96 in the 2023/24 group stage, with fewer draws (13.9% against 20.8%).

What were the biggest upsets?

By rating gap, the largest upset since August 2023 is Bayern Munich 1–2 Augsburg on 24 January 2026, with 360 Elo points between the clubs.

DateMatchCompetitionElo gap
24 Jan 2026Bayern Munich 1–2 AugsburgBundesliga360
8 Mar 2025Bayern Munich 2–3 BochumBundesliga352
4 May 2024Sassuolo 1–0 InterSerie A348
30 Sep 2023Wolves 2–1 Manchester CityPremier League340
1 Feb 2025Espanyol 1–0 Real MadridLa Liga328
13 May 2026Alavés 1–0 BarcelonaLa Liga319
2 Nov 2024Bournemouth 2–1 Manchester CityPremier League318
21 Jan 2024Bayern Munich 0–1 Werder BremenBundesliga315
17 May 2026Paris FC 2–1 Paris Saint-GermainLigue 1308
20 Jan 2026Bodø/Glimt 3–1 Manchester CityChampions League306

In the leagues and the Champions League together, a favourite rated 300 points or more above its opponent lost 12 of 225 matches, about one in 19. Three of the ten largest upsets were home defeats for Bayern.

The Champions League list belongs to Bodø/Glimt. In the 2025/26 season the Norwegian club beat Manchester City 3–1, won 2–1 at Atlético de Madrid, and then knocked out Inter by winning both legs of the play-off, 3–1 and 2–1. Each time it was more than 200 points below its opponent.

Which clubs are the most reliable favourites?

Barcelona. It was the higher-rated side in 122 league matches and won 77.9% of them. Real Madrid won 74.0% of 123, Bayern Munich 73.9% of 111, Inter 71.2% of 125 and Paris Saint-Germain 70.5% of 112.

At the other end, among clubs that were favourites at least 60 times:

  • Crystal Palace won 37.7% of 61 matches as favourite.
  • Brighton won 38.7% of 75 and drew 36.0%.
  • Tottenham won 43.0% of 79 and lost 35.4%, the highest share of defeats in the group.
  • Manchester United won 44.0% of 84.

As underdogs, Espanyol (29.9% of 67 matches), Augsburg (29.5% of 88) and Everton (28.7% of 87) won most often.

Does the top-rated club win the title?

In the leagues, two times in three. The club with the highest Club Elo rating before the first matchday won 10 of the 15 titles in the five leagues from 2023/24 to 2025/26.

Champions of 2023/24 to 2025/26 and their Club Elo rank before the first matchday: the top-rated club won 10 of 15 league titles and no Champions League
Champions of 2023/24 to 2025/26 and their Club Elo rank before the first matchday: the top-rated club won 10 of 15 league titles and no Champions League
  • Thirteen of the 15 champions started in their league's top three by rating. The exceptions were Bayer Leverkusen in 2023/24 (fourth) and Napoli in 2024/25 (seventh).
  • Paris Saint-Germain was top-rated and champion in all three Ligue 1 seasons.
  • The Premier League followed the rating least: Liverpool won in 2024/25 from second, Arsenal in 2025/26 from third.
  • The Champions League went to the top-rated club in none of the three seasons. Real Madrid won in 2023/24 as the second-rated club of the field, Paris Saint-Germain in 2024/25 as the eighth and in 2025/26 as the fifth. Manchester City, top-rated in 2023/24 and 2024/25, went out in the quarter-finals and the play-offs respectively. Liverpool, top-rated in 2025/26, went out in the quarter-finals.

This season the pattern holds in four leagues. After the round of 8 November 2026, Arsenal, Barcelona, Bayern Munich and Paris Saint-Germain lead their tables, and each was its league's top-rated club on day one. Serie A is the exception: Lazio leads Inter by a point after starting the season as the ninth-rated club in Serie A.

What does this mean for Champions League matchday 5?

Matchday 5 of the 2026/27 Champions League is played on 24 and 25 November 2026, and by rating most of its 18 matches have a clear favourite. So far this season the higher-rated club has won 49 of the 72 matches played, or 68%.

Champions League matchday 5, 24 and 25 November 2026: the favourite and the Club Elo gap in all 18 matches, from Sabah v Barcelona (474) to Sporting CP v Manchester United (12)
Champions League matchday 5, 24 and 25 November 2026: the favourite and the Club Elo gap in all 18 matches, from Sabah v Barcelona (474) to Sporting CP v Manchester United (12)
  • Seven clubs are home favourites by 100–199 points: Atlético de Madrid (v Viking), Manchester City (v Napoli), Arsenal (v Borussia Dortmund), Como (v AEK Athens), Bodø/Glimt (v LASK), Inter (v Stuttgart) and Paris Saint-Germain (v Roma). In the Champions League since 2023/24, home favourites with that gap won 79% of 87 matches.
  • Four clubs are away favourites by fewer than 100 points: Liverpool at Club Brugge, Fenerbahçe at Shakhtar, Aston Villa at Galatasaray and Villarreal at Slavia Prague. Away favourites with that gap won 41% of 145 matches and lost 40%.
  • The widest gap is Sabah v Barcelona, 474 points. Away favourites rated 200 points or more above the home side won 76% of 54 matches.
  • The closest match is Sporting CP v Manchester United, with Sporting 12 points above.

The upsets of this season so far: LASK won 3–2 at Sporting CP on 21 October with 259 points between the clubs, Sabah beat Slavia Prague 2–0 (202 points) and Fenerbahçe beat Liverpool 3–2 on 4 November (172 points). Como's 9–1 win at Lens the same night equalled the competition's record winning margin, but by rating it was no upset: Como, in its first Champions League season, was 25 points above Lens.

The leagues return on 20 November. Three matches on the schedule as of 18 November show how the gap and the venue combine: Liverpool v Manchester United on 22 November (Liverpool at home, 86 points above), Arsenal v Manchester City on 29 November (Arsenal at home, 44 points above) and Tottenham v Arsenal on 6 December (Arsenal away, 233 points above). In the leagues, clubs in those three positions won 51%, 44% and 62% of the time.

These are base rates from past results, not forecasts for single matches.

How can you use this on Melbo?

Melbo lists sports markets, football among them. The price of an outcome reads as a probability: 60¢ means the market sees roughly a 60% chance. One detail matters in football more than elsewhere: a market on "Will the club win?" settles as No if the match is drawn, and a quarter of league matches are.

The table gives base rates to compare a price against. It shows how often the higher-rated club won in the five leagues, by rating gap and venue.

Elo gapFavourite at homeFavourite away
0–4944%29%
50–9951%40%
100–14963%48%
150–19972%58%
200–29976%62%
300+87%77%

If a market prices an away favourite at 70¢ and the gap is 120 points, clubs in that position won about half the time. The market may know something the rating does not, such as injuries, a rotated line-up or a match with nothing at stake, so treat the base rate as a starting point. The same approach works in esports: we ran this check for CS2 Majors. If prediction markets are new to you, start with how prediction markets work.

Frequently asked questions

How often do favourites win in football?

About half the time. In 5,756 matches of Europe's five biggest leagues from August 2023 to November 2026, the club with the higher Club Elo rating won 51.3%, drew 25.4% and lost 23.3%. In the Champions League the favourite won 59.8% of 575 matches.

How often do favorites win in soccer compared with other sports?

Less often than in most team sports. A 2006 study by Ben-Naim, Vazquez and Redner covered more than 300,000 games and named the favourite by league record, counting a tie as half an upset. The upset frequency was 45.2% in English top-flight football, 44.1% in baseball, 41.4% in ice hockey, 36.5% in basketball and 36.4% in American football.

How often does the underdog win in football?

The lower-rated club won 23.3% of the 5,756 league matches, close to one in four. Playing at home it won 28.5%, playing away 18.1%. Against a club 300 Elo points or more above it, the underdog won 5.6%.

How often does the home team win in football?

In the five big European leagues since August 2023 the home side won 43.3% of matches, 25.4% were drawn and the away side won 31.4%. When the home side was also the higher-rated club it won 58.2%.

How often do football matches end in a draw?

About one in four: 25.4% of the 5,756 league matches we counted. Between clubs fewer than 50 Elo points apart it was 29.7%, and at 300 points or more 12.3%.

What is Club Elo?

Club Elo is a rating of football clubs built on the Elo system from chess and published at clubelo.com. A club gains points for a win and loses them for a defeat, and the size of the change depends on how surprising the result was and on the goal margin. By its formula, a gap of 100 points means the higher-rated club is expected to take 64% of the match points on offer, with a draw counted as half a win.

What is the biggest football upset since 2023 by rating?

Bayern Munich 1–2 Augsburg in the Bundesliga on 24 January 2026, with 360 Club Elo points between the clubs. In the Champions League it is Bodø/Glimt 3–1 Manchester City on 20 January 2026, a gap of 306 points.

Does the best team win the Champions League?

Not in the last three seasons. The club with the highest Club Elo rating at the start went out in the quarter-finals twice and in the play-offs once. The winners started as the second, eighth and fifth-rated clubs of the field.

How we counted

Results of the 5,756 league matches come from football-data.co.uk: every match of the Premier League, La Liga, the Bundesliga, Serie A and Ligue 1 from the 2023/24 season to 8 November 2026. Results of 503 Champions League matches from 2023/24 to 2025/26 come from the openfootball project, and the 72 matches of the first four matchdays of 2026/27 from fixturedownload.com. Knockout matches are counted by the score after 90 minutes.

Ratings come from the club pages of clubelo.com, downloaded on 18 November 2026 for all 161 clubs. A club's rating before a match is its last published rating from an earlier date. We checked this against Club Elo's own match tables on 1,361 recent matches: the rating gap typically differed by 0.4 points and never by more than 3.0. The favourite is the club with the higher rating, with no adjustment for venue. Adding a 50-point home bonus changes the favourite's share in the leagues from 51.3% to 52.8%.

The results also agree with Club Elo's formula. For clubs 100–149 points apart it expects the higher-rated side to take 67% of the match points on offer, with a draw counted as half a win; in our data it took 68%. At 300 points or more the formula gives 88% and the data 88%.

Three seasons and a few months is a short history. Percentages for small groups, such as the 12 semi-final legs, can move a lot with a handful of results. Fixture dates can still change for television.

What to do next

Note two dates: the leagues resume on 20 November and Champions League matchday 5 is played on 24 and 25 November. Before you form a view on a match, check how many Elo points separate the two clubs and which of them plays at home.

More in this section